My first exposure to the effect of high altitude was in Nepal severalyears ago. I was
on a trek six days' journey from Kathmandu. It is a bizarre and
unnerving feeling to discover that your exercise tolerance is suddenly no more than
a few slow paces, that your pulse races with each step you take, and that you are
obliged to stop to catch your breath every few feet, waiting for the palpitations to
subside while local people of all ages - some carrying heavy
loads - stop, stare, then overtake. I was a fit young medical
student, but my body felt as though it belonged to the victim of some dreadful
disease that I had just been studying - chronic bronchitis, perhaps
emphysema or asbestosis. I developed a hammering headache, and became more
and more breathless, even at rest.
I was lucky, although I didn't know it at the time; these are important
warning signs of acute mountain sickness (AMS). I decided
to come down. In fact, members of the medical profession have a poor track record
when it comes to heeding their own symptoms, and an especially poor record at
high altitude. In a report on seven deaths from mountain sickness on Himalayan
treks, three of the seven who died were themselves doctors.
The tragic fact about deaths from mountain sickness is that they are preventable in
every case. The purpose of this article is therefore threefold: to offer some
practical information about AMS, its warning signs and
prevention; to discuss the merits of the drugs that are sometimes suggested for its
prevention; and to consider other approaches to emergency treatment.
Mountain sickness
The driving force for the absorption of oxygen through the lungs into the bloodstream
is atmospheric pressure - the
'weight' of the column of air that extends for ten
miles or so above our heads. As we ascend, atmospheric pressure is reduced.
Complex mechanisms exist to compensate for the resulting lack of oxygen: these
include an increase in breathing rate and depth, as well as changes in the blood
and tissues that increase their efficiency in carrying and using oxygen. However,
the increased breathing results in reduced levels of carbon dioxide, causing the
body to become more alkaline and, in turn, causing numerous other physiological
changes to occur, not all of which are clearly understood. The kidneys are able to
compensate for changes in alkalinity and acidity, but the process of acclimatisation
to high altitude can take several days - longer under conditions of
low temperature and increased exercise.
AMS tends to occur within two days of exposure. It usually begins with loss of
appetite, headache, nausea, vomiting and sleeplessness. This is the early, benign
form. It may simply resolve, but may also progress to a more serious, so-called
'malignant' form. It should be regarded as an
important warning.
Malignant AMS can be fatal, and it may begin with little or no
warning. Pulmonary oedema develops - a build-up of fluid in the
lung tissues - which further interferes with absorption of oxygen,
leading to breathlessness that persists even at rest. There is also a cough, with
white, pink or frothy sputum, and the lips may turn blue. A build-up of tissue may
also occur in the brain - cerebral oedema. This results in
headache, drowsiness, impaired co-ordination, abnormal or drunken behaviour,
confusion, impaired consciousness and coma. Progression to coma may occur
quite rapidly.
Benign AMS can be handled initially by remaining at the same
altitude until symptoms resolve. If they do not improve, the best treatment is
prompt descent. Victims of malignant AMS need to be
brought down immediately, and most sufferers need to be carried down. Experts
on AMS advise that descent should not be delayed while aid
is summoned, and should start even at night, if necessary.
Mountain sickness is most often a problem at altitudes over 2,600 to 3,000 metres,
though in some people it may occur as low as 2,350 metres. This means that a
hazard exists at many popular travel destinations. Crucial factors in determining
susceptibility to AMS are speed of ascent, and the altitude at
which you sleep. If possible, begin by avoiding sleeping above 3,000 metres for the
first few nights. 'Climb high, Sleep low', is the
rule to follow. Then increase your sleeping altitude by no more than 300 or so
metres per day - even this may be too fast for some people to
adapt to.
High on drugs
While the most important approach to treatment is descent, there is an increasing
trend towards advising trekkers and climbers to consider carrying medication.
There are two drugs for the treatment and prevention of
AMS, acetazolamide (Diamox) and dexamethasone. A third
drug, nifedipine, has shown promising results.
Acetazolamide is a diuretic drug that increases excretion of bicarbonate by the
kidney, tending to counteract the increase in alkalinity referred to above. Some
experts consider that it speeds acclimatisation, while others believe that it may
mask early symptoms that are not a great nuisance in themselves, but that provide
useful warning signs that severe AMS may be developing.
There is no consensus. I have spoken to doctors who swear by acetazolamide,
and to others who are greatly troubled by such side-effects as nausea, tiredness,
poor sleep, and 'pins and needles' in the arms
and legs. There are many cases on record of malignant AMS
occurring despite the use of acetazolamide. It may, nonetheless, provide some
worthwhile benefit.
Dexamethasone is a powerful 'steroid' drug that
has many actions; the most beneficial of these, as far as high altitude is
concerned, is a tendency to reduce oedema. It does not affect acclimatisation, but
merely alleviates some of the symptoms. It is safe for most people when taken for
only short periods, but serious side-effects do occur, especially in people with
diabetes. It may be useful to carry this drug for emergency use in descent.
Portable recompression chambers
The best treatment for a victim of the effects of reduced oxygen pressure is,
obviously, to increase the pressure. Bringing the victim down to a lower altitude is
usually the fastest and simplest way of doing this. However, a new approach also
has its appeal. This is the use of a simple, portable compression chamber. These
look like oversized sleeping bags that can simply be inflated with a foot-pump. It
has to be pumped continuously, to eliminate waste gases, and this can be tiring at
altitude. Alternatively, a carbon dioxide extractor is available for it. A larger model
capable of accommodating two people is also available.
Achievable compression is roughly equivalent to a 1,500-metre descent, depending
on your altitude. This would certainly buy time in an emergency, though there is no
substitute for real descent for people who are seriously ill. It has already been used
with great success by expeditions to remote places where rescue is difficult. Its
cost makes it suitable for groups and expeditions rather than routine treks.
In one case, however, one victim of AMS died while left
unattended overnight in such a chamber. It is very important for people with
AMS to be carefully monitored throughout the course of their
illness and to be brought down if there is no rapid response to the increased
pressure.
Conclusion
The best approach to AMS is prevention, and the most
important measure is gradual ascent. Problems are particularly common with
people on a tight time schedule, who fly in to high-altitude destinations and try to
cram in the maximum amount of sights and activity into the shortest time possible.
One simply cannot expect to be able to fly in to such places as La Paz, Cusco or
Leh and carry on sightseeing without allowing ample time -
perhaps several days - for rest and acclimatisation. Yet there are
cases on record where unfit, elderly people have been booked on tours to Peru
without any warning about the dangers of high altitude, and have died as a result.
Mountain sickness is a preventable illness, and all travellers to high-altitude
regions should make sure they are fully informed about it.